You're scrolling through Zillow looking at properties in San Diego and the numbers look amazing. A $600,000 home that could rent for $250 per night seems like a goldmine. Quick math says that's over $90,000 in annual revenue. Your mortgage payment is maybe $3,500 monthly. Even at 50% occupancy, you're still netting serious profit, right?
Wrong. And this kind of simplified math is exactly why so many people buy vacation rental properties that end up becoming financial disappointments or outright disasters.
The vacation rental industry loves showing you the big gross revenue numbers while conveniently glossing over the dozens of expenses and complications that dramatically reduce what actually ends up in your pocket. Let's talk about the real math that sellers, agents, and even some property managers won't fully explain before you buy.
The Gross Revenue Illusion
Most vacation rental calculations start with gross revenue projections that are wildly optimistic. Someone shows you that a property could generate $250 per night and multiplies that by 365 days to get $91,250 annually.
This number is fiction. Here's why.
Occupancy Reality
No vacation rental achieves 100% occupancy. Even the best properties in the best markets with the best management rarely exceed 75% to 80% occupancy annually. Average properties in good markets typically achieve 55% to 65% occupancy. Below average properties might see 40% or less.
That $91,250 gross revenue at 100% occupancy becomes $54,750 at 60% occupancy. We just cut your projected revenue by 40% before considering any other factors.
Seasonality Impact
San Diego vacation rentals don't earn the same rate year round. A property commanding $300 nightly in July might only get $180 in January. Your average nightly rate across the full year will be significantly lower than peak season rates.
If you're calculating revenue using peak season rates extended across twelve months, you're overestimating by 20% to 40% depending on your property and market segment.
Platform Fees
Airbnb, Vrbo, and Booking.com all charge fees that come directly out of your revenue. These range from 3% to 15% depending on the platform and whether you use their payment processing.
On $54,750 in bookings, assume 10% average platform fees. That's $5,475 gone immediately, leaving you with $49,275 before any actual operating expenses.
Management Fees If Applicable
If you hire professional management at 25% of gross revenue, that's another $13,688 from our example, leaving $35,587.
Even if you self manage, remember your time has value. Managing a vacation rental properly requires 15 to 25 hours monthly. That's opportunity cost even if it's not a direct expense.
We've gone from $91,250 in imaginary revenue to $35,587 in actual net revenue before considering operating expenses. And we haven't paid a single bill yet.
Operating Expenses Everyone Underestimates
Now let's talk about the costs that eat into your remaining revenue. These are real expenses that occur whether your property is booked or empty.
Cleaning Costs
Vacation rentals require professional cleaning after every guest checkout. In San Diego, expect to pay $150 to $300 per cleaning depending on property size.
At 60% occupancy with average 3.5 night stays, that's roughly 63 cleanings annually. At $200 per cleaning, that's $12,600 in annual cleaning costs.
Many hosts try to pass cleaning fees to guests, but high cleaning fees reduce booking conversion rates. It's a delicate balance between recovering costs and staying competitive.
Utilities
Unlike long term rentals where tenants pay utilities, vacation rental owners cover all utilities. Water, electricity, gas, internet, cable, and streaming services.
Vacation rental utility costs run higher than residential because properties are used more intensively and guests are less conservation minded than owners. Expect $300 to $500 monthly depending on property size and amenities. That's $3,600 to $6,000 annually.
Don't forget trash service, pest control, and landscaping if applicable. Add another $1,200 to $2,400 annually for these.
Property Insurance
Standard homeowner's insurance doesn't cover short term rental use. You need specialized vacation rental or commercial insurance policies that cost significantly more.
Where homeowner's insurance might cost $1,500 annually, vacation rental insurance often runs $3,000 to $5,000 or more depending on property value and coverage limits.
Many hosts skip proper insurance to save money. This is insanely risky. One major claim without proper coverage can bankrupt you.
Property Taxes
Property taxes don't change because you're running a vacation rental, but they're often forgotten in profit calculations. In San Diego, expect roughly 1.1% to 1.3% of assessed value annually.
On a $600,000 property, that's $6,600 to $7,800 annually. This comes out of your profit whether you're booked or not.
HOA Fees If Applicable
Many condos and townhomes have HOA fees ranging from $200 to $800 monthly. Some HOAs prohibit short term rentals entirely, so verify before buying.
At $400 monthly, that's another $4,800 annually that many investors forget to include in their calculations.
Transient Occupancy Tax
San Diego collects transient occupancy tax on short term rentals, currently around 10.5% to 12.5% depending on location. This tax is collected from guests but remitted by you.
While technically the guest pays this, it affects your competitive positioning and pricing strategy. Some platforms collect and remit automatically, others require you to handle it.
Failure to properly collect and remit TOT can result in massive penalties and back taxes that destroy profitability.
Permits and Licensing
San Diego requires short term rental permits in most areas, with fees varying by jurisdiction. Annual permit costs range from $250 to $1,500 or more depending on location.
Some areas have moratoriums on new permits. Others have strict requirements around owner occupancy. Research thoroughly before assuming you can legally operate.
Maintenance and Repairs: The Budget Killer
This is where vacation rental math really falls apart for unprepared owners. Vacation rentals experience significantly more wear and tear than traditional rentals or owner occupied homes.
Regular Maintenance
HVAC servicing, water heater maintenance, gutter cleaning, smoke detector testing, pool service if applicable, landscape maintenance, and routine repairs add up quickly.
Budget at minimum $200 to $400 monthly for routine maintenance. That's $2,400 to $4,800 annually, and that's conservative for older properties.
Replacement and Refresh Cycles
Vacation rental furniture, bedding, towels, and decor wear out much faster than residential items. Guests are less careful than owners. Things break, stain, and deteriorate.
Budget 2% to 4% of property value annually for furniture, fixtures, and equipment replacement. On a $600,000 property, that's $12,000 to $24,000 annually.
This might sound high, but mattresses need replacing every three to five years in vacation rentals versus ten years in homes. Sofas last four to six years instead of ten to fifteen. Towels and bedding need frequent replacement.
Interior refresh every three to five years keeps properties competitive as styles and guest expectations evolve. This can easily cost $15,000 to $40,000 depending on scope.
Unexpected Repairs
Water heaters fail. Air conditioners break. Plumbing leaks. Appliances die. These emergencies happen more frequently in vacation rentals due to heavy use.
Keep a reserve of at least $5,000 to $10,000 for unexpected repairs. Budget another $2,000 to $4,000 annually for the inevitable issues that arise.
Guest Damage
Despite security deposits and careful screening, guest damage happens. Most is minor and considered cost of doing business. Occasionally it's significant.
Budget $1,000 to $3,000 annually for guest damage that you'll eat rather than fight over. Security deposits rarely cover actual damage costs after accounting for your time collecting.
Supplies and Amenities
Toilet paper, paper towels, trash bags, dish soap, laundry detergent, coffee, shampoo, and other consumables cost more than you'd expect.
Professional quality linens, kitchen equipment, dishes, glassware, and other guest amenities require ongoing investment.
Budget $100 to $200 monthly, or $1,200 to $2,400 annually for supplies and amenities.
The Real Profit Picture
Let's return to our $600,000 San Diego property example and calculate realistic numbers.
Revenue:
- 60% occupancy at $225 average nightly rate = $49,275 gross revenue
- Less 10% platform fees = $44,348
- Less 25% management if applicable = $33,261 (or keep this but value your 200+ annual hours)
Operating Expenses:
- Cleaning: $12,600
- Utilities: $4,800
- Insurance: $4,000
- Property taxes: $7,200
- HOA fees: $4,800
- Permits: $500
- Maintenance: $3,600
- Furniture replacement: $12,000
- Repairs: $3,000
- Guest damage: $2,000
- Supplies: $1,800
Total Operating Expenses: $56,300
Net Operating Income: $33,261 - $56,300 = -$23,039
Wait, that's negative. We're losing money before even considering mortgage payments.
This is the reality check many vacation rental buyers face after purchasing based on optimistic projections.
Making the Math Actually Work
So does vacation rental investing in San Diego make sense? Absolutely, but only with realistic expectations and proper execution.
Higher Revenue Properties
The example above used modest numbers. Better properties in better locations with professional management achieve higher occupancy and rates.
A property generating $80,000 to $100,000 in actual gross bookings changes the math dramatically. At $90,000 gross with similar expenses, you're actually profitable.
This is why location, property quality, and professional management matter so much. The difference between $50,000 and $90,000 gross revenue is the difference between losing money and making good profit.
Lower Expense Properties
Properties without HOA fees save $4,800 annually. Newer properties with lower maintenance needs reduce those costs. Smaller properties have lower utilities and cleaning costs.
A $500,000 townhome without HOA fees and lower operating costs might achieve profitability at lower revenue levels than our example.
Appreciation and Equity Building
The cash flow math is only part of vacation rental returns. San Diego real estate appreciates over time. Your tenants (guests) are paying down your mortgage.
Even breaking even on cash flow while building equity and benefiting from appreciation can be excellent long term wealth building, especially considering tax benefits.
Tax Benefits
Vacation rental owners can deduct mortgage interest, property taxes, insurance, maintenance, depreciation, and operating expenses. These deductions reduce taxable income significantly.
Depreciation alone provides substantial paper losses that offset other income. Consult a CPA familiar with vacation rental taxation to maximize benefits.
The after tax return picture often looks much better than pre tax cash flow suggests.
The Purchase Analysis Framework
Before buying any vacation rental property, run this analysis.
Revenue Projection
Research actual comparable properties in the area. What are they charging? What's their occupancy based on calendar availability? Use AirDNA or similar tools for market data.
Be conservative. If comps average 65% occupancy, project 55% to 60% for yourself, especially if starting out. If average rates are $225, budget $200 until you're established.
Calculate realistic gross revenue after platform fees. This is your starting point.
Operating Expense Budget
List every expense we've discussed. Get actual quotes for insurance and cleaning. Research HOA fees and property taxes. Budget conservatively for maintenance and repairs.
Add 10% contingency for expenses you haven't thought of. They exist.
Calculate total annual operating expenses.
Net Operating Income
Subtract operating expenses from net revenue after platform fees and management. This is your NOI before mortgage payments.
Positive NOI doesn't guarantee profitability, but negative NOI means you're definitely losing money before debt service.
Debt Service Coverage
Calculate your annual mortgage payment (principal and interest). Divide NOI by annual debt service.
A ratio above 1.25 means you have comfortable cushion. Between 1.0 and 1.25 means tight but viable. Below 1.0 means you're losing money monthly and hoping for appreciation to bail you out.
Cash on Cash Return
Calculate your actual annual cash flow after all expenses including mortgage payments. Divide by your total cash invested (down payment, closing costs, initial furnishing, and reserves).
A 5% to 8% cash on cash return is reasonable for San Diego vacation rentals. Above 10% is excellent. Below 3% is marginal unless you're playing a pure appreciation game.
Red Flags That Kill Deals
Certain warning signs indicate a property won't work financially no matter how nice it looks.
Unrealistic Seller Projections
Sellers often provide "pro forma" income projections that are wildly optimistic. If projected revenue seems too good compared to actual comps, it probably is.
Trust your own research over seller claims. They're motivated to paint rosy pictures.
High HOA Fees
HOA fees above $400 monthly significantly hurt cash flow. Some expensive buildings charge $800+ monthly which makes profitable operation nearly impossible.
Also verify the HOA allows short term rentals and review CC&Rs carefully. Some have restrictions that effectively prohibit vacation rental operation.
Deferred Maintenance
Properties with obvious deferred maintenance will hit you with major repair costs immediately. Old roof, aging HVAC, outdated electrical, plumbing issues. These problems cost tens of thousands to address.
Get thorough inspections and budget realistically for addressing any issues found. Sellers rarely credit full repair costs in negotiations.
Saturated Markets
Research how many vacation rentals operate in the immediate area. Oversaturated markets drive down rates and occupancy as you compete with dozens of similar properties.
Look for areas with strong demand but limited supply. These markets support better rates and occupancy.
Regulatory Risk
Some San Diego neighborhoods have uncertain regulatory futures for vacation rentals. Permit moratoriums, neighbor opposition, and changing ordinances create risk.
Buy in areas with clear legal frameworks and stable regulations. Risky areas might work until they don't, leaving you with a property you can't legally operate.
The Financing Reality
Vacation rental financing is more expensive than primary residence loans. Expect higher interest rates, larger down payments, and stricter qualification.
Down Payment Requirements
Most lenders require 20% to 25% down for vacation rental properties. Some want 30% or more. Plan accordingly.
A $600,000 property needs $120,000 to $150,000 down payment plus closing costs and reserves. You're looking at $140,000 to $170,000 total cash needed.
Interest Rates
Vacation rental loans carry interest rates roughly 0.5% to 1.0% higher than primary residence rates. This significantly impacts your monthly payment and overall profitability.
Qualification Standards
Lenders scrutinize vacation rental purchases more carefully than primary residences. Expect stricter income verification and debt to income requirements.
Some lenders won't count projected vacation rental income toward qualification until you have operating history. Others will count only 75% of projected income.
The Time Investment Nobody Mentions
Even with professional management, vacation rental ownership requires time and attention most buyers don't anticipate.
Initial Setup
Furnishing, designing, photographing, and setting up a new vacation rental takes weeks of focused effort or significant expense if you hire it out.
Budget 60 to 100 hours of your time or $15,000 to $30,000 to hire professionals for complete setup.
Ongoing Oversight
Even with management, you're reviewing financial reports, approving maintenance expenditures, making strategic decisions, and staying informed about property performance.
Plan on 3 to 5 hours monthly minimum for oversight and decision making.
Major Issues
When significant problems arise, they require your attention regardless of management. Foundation issues, major repairs, insurance claims, legal matters. These can consume dozens of hours.
Property Visits
Unless you live locally, you'll need to visit periodically to assess condition, meet with management, and ensure everything meets standards.
Budget for several trips annually if you're investing from out of area.
When Vacation Rentals Make Financial Sense
Despite the sobering math we've discussed, vacation rental investing can be excellent wealth building under the right conditions.
Sufficient Capital
You need adequate cash reserves beyond down payment and closing costs. A $25,000 to $50,000 reserve cushion ensures you can handle unexpected expenses without financial stress.
Undercapitalized investors face disaster when major repairs or slow booking periods create cash flow crunches.
Long Term Perspective
Vacation rentals work best as five to ten year holds minimum. Short term flipping usually doesn't work because transaction costs eat profits.
Appreciation, equity building, and tax benefits compound over time. Patient investors build significant wealth. Impatient ones lose money.
Professional Management
Unless you're truly passionate about hospitality and have abundant time, professional management is essential for sustainable success.
The revenue improvements professional managers deliver through better pricing, occupancy, and operations typically exceed their fees while eliminating your operational burden.
Stay Classy Homes clients consistently report that professional management increased their revenue enough to more than cover management fees while giving them their lives back.
Strong Market Selection
Buy in markets with strong year round demand, limited supply, legal clarity, and positive long term trends. San Diego qualifies but specific neighborhoods vary.
A great property in a weak market struggles. An average property in a strong market thrives.
Realistic Expectations
Understanding the actual math and setting realistic financial expectations prevents disappointment. Vacation rentals aren't get rich quick schemes.
They're solid long term wealth building tools for investors who do the math properly and execute well.
The Stay Classy Homes Advantage
We help property owners understand the real math before and after purchase. Our free income projections use conservative assumptions based on actual comparable property performance.
We'll show you realistic gross revenue, actual operating expenses, and honest net income projections. No sugar coating or unrealistic optimism.
Joseph Malvar said working with us "significantly enhanced the profitability" of his property. Mike Valenzona called the service "top notch" and appreciated our "experience, knowledge, and creativity" in improving performance.
These results come from understanding the math and executing strategies that maximize revenue while controlling expenses.
Running the Numbers on Your Potential Purchase
Considering a vacation rental purchase in San Diego? We'll help you analyze the actual numbers before you commit.
We'll evaluate the property, research comparable performance, project realistic revenue, estimate operating expenses, and show you the real profit picture.
This analysis costs you nothing but could save you from an expensive mistake or confirm a solid investment opportunity.
Call (619) 738 6199 to discuss your potential purchase. We'll give you honest analysis without sales pressure because we'd rather manage profitable properties for successful owners than take on investments doomed to disappoint.
Your Path Forward
Vacation rental investing in San Diego can build substantial wealth for investors who understand the real math and execute properly. Properties that look marginal on paper often perform excellently with professional management in the right locations.
The key is going in with eyes wide open about actual costs, realistic revenue, and proper execution requirements.
Don't buy based on wishful thinking and optimistic projections. Buy based on conservative analysis that still shows solid returns. Then execute excellently to exceed those conservative projections.
That's how successful vacation rental investors build wealth over time.
Leave a comment
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.