San Diego vacation rental owners are closing out 2025 with a harsh reality: revenue is down across the board, and many operators who were profitable in 2024 are now struggling to break even. As we head into 2026, the challenges aren't going away—they're intensifying. If you've noticed your bookings slowing down, your nightly rates getting undercut, or your occupancy rates dropping throughout 2025, you need to understand what's happening and prepare for an even more competitive 2026. The market dynamics that crushed profits this year will only get worse without strategic changes to how you operate your vacation rental.
Struggling with declining revenue heading into 2026? Contact us to get a professional property assessment and 2026 revenue recovery plan, or call 619-738-6199.
The 2025 Revenue Collapse in Hard Numbers
The data from 2025 tells a stark story about what happened to San Diego Airbnb revenue this year, and it's setting up challenging conditions for 2026:
| Performance Metric | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 | Two-Year Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average Occupancy Rate | 62% | 58% | 55% | -7 percentage points |
| Average Daily Rate | $285 | $268 | $255 | -11% decline |
| Average Monthly Revenue | $5,481 | $4,938 | $4,576 | -17% decline |
| Median Annual Revenue | $65,772 | $59,256 | $54,912 | -$10,860 loss |
Most hosts have seen their revenue drop 15-20% over the past two years. Properties that generated $70,000 annually in 2023 brought in just $56,000-59,500 in 2025. That's a $10,500-13,500 annual decline—over $1,000 less per month than just two years ago.
The bottom quartile has been hit even harder:
| Performance Tier | 2023 Monthly Revenue | 2025 Monthly Revenue | Decline |
|---|---|---|---|
| Top 10% | $14,200 | $13,000 | -8% |
| Top 25% | $8,840 | $7,966 | -10% |
| Median | $5,481 | $4,576 | -17% |
| Bottom 25% | $3,120 | $2,396 | -23% |
Notice that top performers maintained relatively strong performance with only 8-10% declines, while median and lower-tier properties were devastated with 17-23% revenue drops. This trend is accelerating as we enter 2026.
The Oversaturation That Defined 2025
San Diego's vacation rental market reached critical mass in 2025. While the STRO ordinance caps were designed to control supply, thousands of licenses were issued before those caps were reached. Here's where the market stood by late 2025:
| License Tier | Licenses Issued | Status | Market Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tier 1 (Part-Time) | 142 | Unlimited availability | Minimal competition impact |
| Tier 2 (Home Sharing) | 2,386 | Unlimited availability | Significant room rental competition |
| Tier 3 (Whole Home) | 4,655 | 896 remaining | Heavy whole-home competition |
| Tier 4 (Mission Beach) | 1,097 | 0 available (waitlist closed) | Maximum saturation reached |
| Total Active STRs | 8,280 | Near capacity | Severe oversupply |
Nearly 6,000 whole-home vacation rentals competed for guests throughout 2025. This oversupply drove the price wars and occupancy drops that crushed host earnings. As we enter 2026, these same properties will continue fighting for bookings, with no relief in sight from the supply side.
The few remaining Tier 3 licenses (896 as of November 2025) will likely be claimed within the first quarter of 2026, permanently capping the market. But the damage from oversaturation is already done—the competition level heading into 2026 will be just as intense as what hosts faced in 2025.
Why 2025 Seasonal Patterns Signal Trouble for 2026
San Diego's traditional seasonal patterns shifted dramatically in 2025, and these changes are projected to continue into 2026:
| Season | 2023 Performance | 2025 Performance | Change | 2026 Outlook |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Peak Summer (Jun-Aug) | 68% occupancy, $450 ADR, $9,520/mo | 61.7% occupancy, $422 ADR, $8,671/mo | -9% revenue | Further compression expected |
| Shoulder (Mar-May, Sep-Oct) | 61% occupancy, $340 ADR, $6,527/mo | 56% occupancy, $310 ADR, $5,785/mo | -11% revenue | Continued softness likely |
| Low Season (Jan-Feb, Nov-Dec) | 54% occupancy, $360 ADR, $6,156/mo | 48.6% occupancy, $331 ADR, $4,695/mo | -24% revenue | Starting 2026 weak |
We're entering 2026 with the worst low-season performance in recent history. January and February 2026 are projected to be particularly challenging based on forward bookings data. Hosts who relied on relatively stable winter income to cover mortgages throughout 2025 will face the same struggles in early 2026.
The concerning trend is that peak summer performance also declined in 2025. If summer 2026 follows the same trajectory, even the high season won't provide the revenue cushion it once did.
The Expense Crisis That Crushed 2025 Profits Will Continue
Even hosts who maintained decent occupancy in 2025 saw profits evaporate because expenses skyrocketed. These costs will remain elevated or increase further in 2026:
| Expense Category | 2023 Average | 2025 Average | 2026 Projected | Total Increase |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly Utilities | $250 | $325 | $340-360 | +36-44% |
| Per-Cleaning Cost | $120 | $165 | $175-190 | +46-58% |
| Monthly Insurance | $175 | $285 | $300-325 | +71-86% |
| Maintenance/Repairs (annual) | $2,400 | $3,360 | $3,600-3,840 | +50-60% |
| Property Tax (annual) | $4,800 | $5,376 | $5,700-6,000 | +19-25% |
| Platform Fees (% of revenue) | 3-5% | 3-5% | 3-5% | Same % but of lower revenue |
Let's look at the profit impact on a median-performing property heading into 2026:
| Income/Expense Item | 2023 | 2025 | 2026 Projected | Change from 2023 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly Gross Revenue | $5,481 | $4,576 | $4,350-4,675 | -15-21% |
| TOT/TMD (12.5%) | -$685 | -$572 | -$544-584 | -15-21% |
| Platform Fees (4%) | -$219 | -$183 | -$174-187 | -21-21% |
| Cleaning (6 turnovers) | -$720 | -$990 | -$1,050-1,140 | +46-58% |
| Utilities | -$250 | -$325 | -$340-360 | +36-44% |
| Maintenance Reserve (7%) | -$384 | -$320 | -$305-327 | -21-15% |
| Insurance | -$175 | -$285 | -$300-325 | +71-86% |
| Supplies | -$150 | -$175 | -$185-200 | +23-33% |
| Net Operating Income | $2,898 | $1,726 | $1,452-1,552 | -46-50% |
If you're barely breaking even now at the end of 2025, 2026 looks even bleaker without significant operational changes. Properties that generated $2,000-3,000 monthly profit in 2023 are projected to operate at losses or minimal profits in 2026.
Hotels Dominated in 2025 and Will Push Harder in 2026
The hotel industry fully recovered in 2025, and they're positioned to take even more market share in 2026. Here's the competitive landscape as we enter the new year:
| Accommodation Type | Average Nightly Cost | Included Amenities | Additional Fees | Total Cost (3 nights) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hotel (Downtown) | $200/night | Parking, WiFi, breakfast, housekeeping, loyalty points | None | $600 |
| Airbnb (Downtown) | $180/night | WiFi only | $150 cleaning + $75 service + $30 parking | $765 |
| Hotel Advantage | — | More services, rewards programs | — | $165 savings |
For business travelers and couples without kids, hotels became the obvious choice in 2025. This trend will accelerate in 2026 as hotels launch new loyalty programs and promotional campaigns targeting the January-February travel slump.
Major hotel chains are planning aggressive 2026 marketing campaigns specifically targeting travelers who switched to vacation rentals during the pandemic. Their message: predictable quality, no surprise fees, earn points for future stays.
Guest Expectations Rose in 2025 While Hosts Earned Less
Guests demanded more throughout 2025 while paying less, and these expectations are now firmly established heading into 2026. Here's what's now considered baseline versus what used to be premium:
| Amenity/Feature | 2023 Status | 2025 Status | 2026 Requirement | Cost to Provide |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fast WiFi (100+ Mbps) | Premium | Required baseline | Minimum 200+ Mbps | $100-150/month |
| Smart TVs with streaming | Nice to have | Required baseline | Multiple TVs expected | $600-1,200 upfront |
| Professional coffee maker | Premium | Required baseline | Specialty options expected | $300-600 upfront |
| Quality mattresses/bedding | Standard | Premium expected | Luxury hotel-grade | $1,000-2,000 per bed |
| Work-from-home setup | Rare | Increasingly expected | Multiple workspaces | $500-1,000 |
| Welcome amenities | Premium touch | Expected standard | Personalized touches | $20-40 per booking |
| 24/7 concierge service | Luxury | Expected | Instant response expected | Significant time commitment |
Any property entering 2026 without these baseline amenities will struggle to compete. Guest tolerance for "good enough" properties disappeared in 2025 and won't return in 2026.
How Review Scores Determined 2025 Success (And Will Make or Break 2026)
Your review score determined your success or failure in 2025, and the threshold for "good enough" has risen even higher heading into 2026. Here's how review scores directly impacted bookings in 2025:
| Review Score Range | Search Visibility | Booking Conversion Rate | Typical Occupancy | Revenue Impact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4.9-5.0 stars | Premium placement | 18-22% | 75-86% | Baseline (best) |
| 4.8-4.89 stars | Good placement | 12-16% | 65-75% | -15% vs top tier |
| 4.7-4.79 stars | Average placement | 8-12% | 55-65% | -30% vs top tier |
| 4.5-4.69 stars | Below average | 4-7% | 40-50% | -50% vs top tier |
| Below 4.5 stars | Severely limited | 2-4% | 25-35% | -70% vs top tier |
If you ended 2025 below 4.8 stars, you're starting 2026 at a severe disadvantage. Platform algorithms are reportedly making review scores even more important in their 2026 ranking updates.
The 2026 reality: Properties below 4.7 stars will be essentially invisible in search results. If you're not already at 4.8+, getting there needs to be your primary focus for Q1 2026.
Platform Algorithm Changes Throughout 2025 Predict 2026 Challenges
Airbnb and Vrbo made significant algorithm changes throughout 2025 that will continue impacting hosts in 2026:
| Ranking Factor | Impact on Search Visibility | Typical Performance Gap | 2026 Importance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Instant Book Enabled | High | 40% more visibility | Increasing |
| Response Time <10 minutes | Very High | 60% more inquiries | Critical |
| Review Score 4.8+ | Critical | 3x more bookings | Mandatory threshold |
| Cancellation Rate <1% | High | 35% boost | Strictly enforced |
| Calendar Availability >90% | Medium | 20% improvement | Increasing weight |
| Competitive Pricing (bottom 40%) | High | 50% more views | More important |
Platform representatives have indicated that 2026 will see even more algorithm refinement, with greater emphasis on "host reliability" metrics. Properties that weren't optimized for these factors in 2025 will fall even further behind in 2026 search results.
What Separated Winners from Losers in 2025
The hosts who maintained or grew revenue in 2025 did specific things that will be even more critical in 2026:
| Success Factor | Struggling Properties (2025) | Thriving Properties (2025) | Revenue Impact | 2026 Necessity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Photography | DIY iPhone photos (2+ years old) | Professional shots (<12 months) | +35% bookings | Mandatory |
| Interior Design | Original furnishings, no updates | Refreshed design every 2-3 years | +25% ADR | Critical differentiator |
| Response Time | 2-6 hours average | <10 minutes (often automated) | +60% inquiries | Algorithm requirement |
| Pricing Strategy | Manual, rarely adjusted | Dynamic software-based | +15-20% revenue | Essential for competitiveness |
| Instant Book | Disabled | Enabled | +40% visibility | Near-mandatory |
| Calendar Management | Blocks out personal dates | Always available | +20% bookings | Algorithm penalty for blocking |
| Guest Experience | Basic checklist approach | Thoughtful touches, local guide | +0.3-0.5 star rating | Survival requirement |
| Review Management | Responds occasionally | Responds to every review within 24hrs | Better algorithm ranking | Expected standard |
Properties that didn't make these changes in 2025 fell behind. Those that don't implement them in early 2026 will be priced out of competitiveness entirely.
What You Must Do in Q1 2026 to Survive
If your San Diego vacation rental underperformed in 2025, you have a narrow window in Q1 2026 to turn things around before peak summer season. Here's what recovery requires:
| Recovery Action | Investment Required | Timeline | Revenue Impact | Priority for 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Professional Photography | $400-800 one-time | January completion | +30-40% bookings | CRITICAL - Do first |
| Design Refresh (moderate) | $5,000-15,000 | Jan-Feb implementation | +20-25% ADR | HIGH - Before summer |
| Dynamic Pricing Software | $25-50/month | January setup | +15-20% revenue | CRITICAL - Immediate |
| Professional Management | 20-30% of revenue ongoing | January transition | +25-35% gross revenue | HIGH - If self-managing failed |
| Operations Overhaul | Time investment or mgmt fee | Jan-Mar | +0.3-0.5 star rating | CRITICAL - Must reach 4.8+ |
| Platform Optimization | Minimal cost, time investment | January completion | +20-30% visibility | CRITICAL - Algorithm changes |
January 2026 is your window. Properties that make these changes by February will be positioned for summer success. Those that wait until May or June will have already lost the critical summer booking window.
The Reality Check for 2026
San Diego's vacation rental market will be even more competitive in 2026 than it was in 2025. The supply constraints that defined 2025 will continue. Guest expectations that rose throughout 2025 are now permanent. The expenses that crushed margins in 2025 aren't coming down.
Here's what it takes to succeed in 2026 versus what worked in previous years:
| Market Phase | 2020-2022 (Boom Era) | 2025 (Transition Year) | 2026 (New Reality) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Competition Level | Low - Limited listings | High - Market saturated | Intense - Cap reached |
| Guest Expectations | Moderate - Happy with basics | High - Demanding resort quality | Premium - Hotel-level service expected |
| Success Requirements | Basic listing, decent photos | Professional operation required | Complete optimization mandatory |
| Price Sensitivity | Low - Guests paid premiums | High - Comparison shopping | Extreme - Every dollar matters |
| Time Investment | Part-time management worked | Full-time or professional mgmt | Professional management near-essential |
| Profit Margins | 60-75% net margins | 40-55% for well-managed | 35-50% even with optimization |
| Algorithm Complexity | Simple - Just list and book | Complex - Constant optimization | Critical - Perfect execution required |
Amateur operators who survived 2025 will be forced out in 2026. Only professional operations that treat vacation rentals as a serious business will maintain profitable operations.
Your 2026 Action Plan
If you want to turn around declining revenue as we enter 2026, here's your immediate action plan:
Week 1 (Early January):
- Get professional photography scheduled (book now before peak season rush)
- Enable instant book on all platforms
- Implement dynamic pricing software
- Audit your current review score and identify improvement areas
Week 2-3 (Mid-January):
- Update all listing photos with professional shots
- Refresh listing descriptions to highlight 2026 amenities
- Review and lower cleaning fees to improve total price competitiveness
- Set up automated response templates for common questions
Week 4-6 (Late January-Early February):
- Complete any design refreshes or amenity upgrades
- Optimize calendar availability (remove personal blocks)
- Audit competitor listings and adjust pricing strategy
- Implement guest experience improvements to drive 5-star reviews
February-March:
- Monitor performance metrics weekly
- Continue optimizing based on booking patterns
- Build up positive reviews before summer season
- Adjust strategy based on early 2026 results
At Stay Classy Homes, we're helping property owners implement complete 2026 recovery plans throughout January. Our approach includes:
- Interior design transformation that makes properties photograph beautifully and command premium rates for summer 2026
- Revenue management through dynamic pricing optimized for 2026 market conditions
- Operations excellence that delivers 5-star guest experiences consistently
- Complete compliance handling so you never worry about permits, taxes, or regulations
- Professional photography that makes your listing stand out in crowded 2026 search results
Properties that engage professional management in January typically see revenue improvements of 25-50% by summer season. Those that wait until spring have already missed critical booking windows.
Don't let 2026 be another year of declining revenue. The market has fundamentally changed, and properties that don't adapt will continue losing money. Call us at 619-738-6199 for a free property assessment and customized 2026 revenue recovery plan. We'll show you exactly what needs to change and how much revenue improvement you can realistically expect.
The difference between struggling through another disappointing year and actually thriving in 2026 comes down to the decisions you make in the next 30 days. Start the year right with a clear plan and professional execution.
If your San Diego vacation rental is underperforming and you're ready to turn it around, call us at 619-738-6199 for a free property assessment and revenue recovery plan. The market has changed, but opportunities still exist for operators willing to adapt and execute professionally.
Leave a comment
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.